Wednesday, April 16, 2025

Beyond Illusion: Brecht's Epic Theatre and the Buddhist Concept of Non-Self

 

Introduction

Epic theatre (German: episches Theater ) is a theatrical movement that emerged in the early to mid-20th century. It was shaped by the theories and practices of theatre practitioners like Bertolt Brecht, who responded to the political climate of the time by creating a new form of political theatre. At a time when melodrama, realism, and naturalism were popular theatre forms, Brecht rejected what he perceived as the "shallow spectacle, manipulative plots, and heightened emotion" of melodrama. He proposed epic theatre as a major alternative, particularly to the early naturalistic approach (and later "psychological realism") developed by Konstantin Stanislavski. These naturalistic styles tried to recreate real life on stage, with the idea that the audience should believe the story and characters in the play were real. Brecht saw this traditional theatre as escapism, a place "where the audience could forget about their lives for a while", and criticized that it "did not make the audience think" which he "saw as a huge waste of an audience." He wanted people to question and challenge, not simply accept and enjoy, and therefore created a new form of theatre designed to make the audience question and think about what they were watching. A staunch Marxist, Brecht’s plays often had a political and social message.

Alienation Effects

In the realistic theatre of illusion, Brecht argued, the spectator tended to identify with the characters on stage and become emotionally involved with them, rather than being stirred to think about his own life. To encourage a critical perspective, Brecht introduced the Verfremdungseffekt , or alienation effect. This technique aimed to direct the audience’s attention to the artifice of the theatre. It involved disrupting the audience's immersion in the narrative by "doing something unexpected", breaking the rhythm of the scene, so that "the audience stops getting lost in the emotion, story and characters" and "are able to start to think and question." It was "seen as a ‘slap in the face with a wet fish’ to wake everyone up." The idea with ‘alienation effects’ was to constantly remind the audience they were in a theatre, watching a play. These techniques break the illusion of drama, so the audience does not get lost in the story or the characters, but instead "are constantly reminded that these are actors communicating ideas and situations to them."

Techniques of Epic Theatre

Some of the techniques that were used by Brecht were:

  • Plays were performed with the house lights on so that audience members remained aware of each other during the performance.
  • Music and dancing were used to break up the action of the play, or scenes were sung rather than spoken.
  • Placards were used to give information to the audience.
  • All of the characters might be dressed in black rather than individually costumed.
  • Brecht preferred to call the audience ‘spectators’ and his focus was always on the society being presented in the play, not individual characters;
  • Events in plays were sometimes told from the viewpoint of a single storyteller.

He believed that the actor’s job was merely to show what happened, and did not want actors to identify with the character or to play the role realistically, which was the opposite of Stanislavski’s purpose.

The Concept of Anatta

Brecht’s theatre style and techniques of alienation provide a way to gain an understanding of the ‘no self’ or ‘anatta’ doctrine preached by the Buddha. Anatta means ‘no self,’ and the doctrine of anatta is one of the three characteristics or marks of existence, alongside impermanence (anithya ) and suffering ( dukkha ), declared by the Buddha as doorways to liberation ( Vimukthi Mukha ). Being subject to conditionality, the teachings state, all things (including people and sentient beings) are impermanent and therefore cause suffering; anything that causes suffering cannot be taken as ‘self’ and thus is ‘anatta’.

The analogy of a cinema experience: Cinema is like an illusion that can captivate the viewer, binding them to the story and characters unfolding on the screen. Although what is displayed on the screen is a series of moving images produced by light rays projected onto it, the viewer, not seeing this reality, perceives them as real events and becomes attached to them. For example, when watching an action movie, the viewer becomes shocked, frightened, and emotional due to the thrilling scenes, car crashes, and burning buildings depicted in it. They grieve when their favorite character is defeated in fight scenes. This is because the viewer projects their mental conceptions onto the events and characters unfolding on the screen, becoming emotionally attached to it. They are unaware of the acting, makeup, technical effects, and editing involved in the film's production. However, if the film's director were watching the same movie, they would not experience such unusual joy, sadness, or shock. This is because they are well aware of all the makeup, acting, technical effects, and editing that took place behind the scenes of the production they directed. They know that the burning buildings that appear real are actually cardboard models and that the damaged vehicles are toy cars. In a way, if the viewer also understood how they are being deceived in front of the screen, instead of being thrilled and frightened, they would find it amusing.

The emotional attachments as said (to the illusion created on the screen) that arise within the individual viewer are due to his or her mistaken perception driven by delusion. Just as Brecht sought to break the theatrical illusion to reveal a deeper truth, the Buddha's teachings aim to penetrate the illusion of self to reveal the path to liberation.

Perception of Self & Cause for Suffering

The Buddha identified these emotional attachments as clinging (upadana). He saw how people are deluded in this manner, embracing what is essentially unwholesome as wholesome, impermanent as permanent, unpleasant as pleasant and non-self as self. The cinema screen made of fabric is not self, and the images created by light rays projected on the screen are not self, however, the spectator ignores this and tends to grasp the superficial storyline as real. There is no difference to this and our real-life experiences. We project perceptions of self that arise in the mind on external objects and tend to believe that our conceptions belong to them or, in other words, that they are real, like in the cinema experience. According to the Buddha, this is the cause of much of the distress and pain humans inflict upon themselves and others through greed, fear, ignorance, hatred and self-deception.

Epic Theatre and Freedom from Suffering

Bertolt Brecht believed that theatre should appeal not to the spectator's feelings but to his (or her) reason. While still providing entertainment, it should be strongly didactic and capable of provoking social change. Brecht revolutionized theatre and turned it into a tool for looking at the big issues that affect society. He made it possible for theatre to make a difference. The Buddha, on the other hand, saw beyond the world and revealed how we are entrapped in an existence of suffering due to delusion of grasping to self-views, therefore being unable to see things as they really are. He taught that liberation from this suffering requires the cultivation of Right View (Samma Ditti). This Right View dispels ignorance and gives rise to the knowledge (vidya) of reality. It is the key to understanding suffering, its cause, its end, and the path to its end. This understanding foster detachment from internally generated conceptions, removing craving, and culminating in the freedom of Nibbana."

No comments:

Post a Comment

Beyond Illusion: Brecht's Epic Theatre and the Buddhist Concept of Non-Self

  Introduction Epic theatre (German: episches Theater ) is a theatrical movement that emerged in the early to mid-20th century. It was sha...